The false promise of herd immunity for COVID-19
Why proposals to largely let the virus run its course — embraced by Donald Trump’s administration and others — could bring “untold death and suffering”.
Samuel V. Scarpino #BlackLivesMatter
129d ago
Without a vaccine, "herd immunity" strategies for #COVID19 are deeply unethical, will lead to huge loss of life, will cause untold economic damage, & are *very* unlikely to work. Everyone needs to stop & read @cragcrest's *fantastic* new piece in @nature
227
Herd Immunity is not "nature's way."
As @K_G_Andersen says, "Never before have we reached herd immunity via natural infection with a novel virus." The explainer you need by @cragcrest
And now @nature explains why we should not seek herd immunity through uncontrolled transmission in the absence of a vaccine
"Arguments in favour of allowing the virus to run its course largely unchecked share a misunderstanding about what herd immunity is, and how best to achieve it. Here, Nature answers five questions about the controversial idea."
Arguments in favour of allowing coronavirus to run its course largely unchecked share a misunderstanding about what herd immunity is, and how best to achieve it. Here, we answers five questions about the controversial idea.
Nice explanation of where the misunderstandings about herd immunity are coming from and why this approach would be so massively deadly -- and still not work. By @cragcrest on @SciAm via @NatureNews
Clear answers from Nature, to five key questions on Herd Immunity - 'The false promise of herd immunity for COVID-19'
"The false promise of herd immunity for COVID-19" at @NatureNews w/ comments from @estercsabino on our recent preprint looking at SARS-CoV-2 seroprevalence in Manaus (doi.org/10.1101/2020.0…).
Check here answers to five questions about herd immunity:
nature.com/articles/d4158…
Many will question the ethics of a vaccine challenge trial (intentionally infecting the virus)
nature.com/articles/d4158…
But that's nothing compared with the unethical, reckless strategy to achieve herd immunity without a vaccine
nature.com/articles/d4158… pic.twitter.com/4vi1pnZVOA
Arguments in favour of allowing coronavirus to run its course largely unchecked share a misunderstanding about what herd immunity is, and how best to achieve it. Here, we answers five questions about the controversial idea.
"We have to face reality - never before have we reached herd immunity via natural infection with a novel virus, and #SARSCoV2 is unfortunately no different." - @K_G_Andersen @NatureNews
Zwar auf Englisch, aber sehr gute Zusammenfassung der Probleme von einer COVID-19 "Herdenimmunität via Infektion (Durchseuchung)":
The false promise of herd immunity for COVID-19
"The false promise of #HerdImmunity for #COVID19" in @nature:
nature.com/articles/d4158… pic.twitter.com/4cu3BHMKSI
"#COVID19 #HerdImmunity Strategies Could Bring 'Untold Death and Suffering'" scientificamerican.com/article/covid-… by @cragcrest via @sciam cc @jeremycsnyder @marco_zenone @srmarcon
"Vaccination is the only ethical path to herd immunity."
nature.com/articles/d4158…
Interesting analysis of estimates of herd immunity. I didn't realise that low estimates are based on intense social distancing which means that achieving herd immunity at lower thresholds doesn't mean life goes back anywhere near normal
The false promise of herd immunity for COVID-19: Why proposals to largely let the virus run its course — embraced by Donald Trump’s administration and others — could bring “untold death and suffering”.
Please stop quoting numbers on heard immunity or even infection rates without uncertainty estimates. Uncertainty estimates are essential to making risk assessments.
The false promise of herd immunity for #COVID19 nature.com/articles/d4158… Letting the virus run its course, a strategy embraced by Donald Trump’s administration and others, could bring “untold death and suffering”.
Don’t take it from me, read this @nature piece.
“Surrendering to the virus” is not a defensible plan.
The false promise of #HerdImmunity for #COVID19. Why proposals to largely let the virus run its course could bring “untold death and suffering,” by @cragcrest nature.com/articles/d4158… via @NatureNews @Monika_Dutt #GlobalHealth
“We have to face reality — never before have we reached herd immunity via natural infection with a novel virus, and SARS-CoV-2 is unfortunately no different.” Nature unpacks 'herd immunity' as cases in Manaus-thought to have reached the threshold-rise
Why proposals to largely let the virus run its course — embraced by Donald Trump’s administration and others — could bring “untold death and suffering”. nature.com/articles/d4158… via @cragcrest
A lucid piece on the illusion of unchecked infections to reach #herdimmunity. #COVID19.
The false promise of herd immunity for COVID-19: "Why proposals to largely let the virus run its course — embraced by Donald Trump’s administration and others — could bring “untold death and suffering”"
scientificamerican.com/article/covid-… Herd Immunity approach would lead to a catastrophic loss of human lives without necessarily speeding up society’s return to normal
via @sciam
The false promise of herd immunity for COVID-19 - Nature nature.com/articles/d4158… #covid19 #herdimmunity
nature.com/articles/d4158…
The development of SARS-CoV-2 vaccine development is well underway. Vaccination is still the only ethical path to herd immunity. Thanks @cragcrest for following up my work and bringing this hot scientific topic to the public.
@NatureNews
@CUHKMedicine
